Leaderboard

ASSET GLOBAL RATING SCALE OF OPERATIVE PERFORMANCE

Please circle the number corresponding to the candidate’s performance regardless of the candidate’s level of training.


Safety

1
Significant damage to articular cartilage or soft tissue
2
3
Insignificant damage to articular cartilage or soft tissue
4
5
No damage to articular cartilage or soft tissue

Field of View

1
Narrow field of view, inadequate arthroscope or lightsource positioning
2
3
Moderate field of view, adequate arthroscope or lightsource positioning
4
5
Expansive field of view, optimal arthroscope or lightsource positioning

Camera Dexterity

1
Awkward or graceless movements, fails to keep camera centered and correctly oriented (horizon)
2
3
Appropriate use of camera, occasionaly needs to reposition
4
5
Graceful and dexterous throughout procedure with camera always centered and correctly oriented

Instrument Dexterity

1
Overly tentative or awkward with instruments, unable to consistently direct instruments to targets
2
3
Careful, controlled use of instruments, occasionally misses targets
4
5
Confident and accurate use of all instruments

Bi-Manual Dexterity

1
Unable to use both hands or no coordination between hands
2
3
Uses both hands but occasionally fails to coordinate movement of camera and instruments
4
5
Uses both hands to coordinate camera and instrument positioning for optimal performance

Flow of Procedure

1
Frequently stops operating or persists without progress, multiple unsuccessful attempts prior to completing tasks
2
3
Steady progression of operative procedure with few unsuccessful attempts prior to completing tasks
4
5
Obviously planned course of procedure, fluid transition from one task to the next with no unsuccessful attempts

Quality of Procedure

1
Inadequate or incomplete final product
2
3
Adequate final product with only minor flaws that do not require correction
4
5
Optimal final product with no flaws

Autonomy (if appropriate)

1
Unable to complete procedure even with intervention(s)
2
Able to complete procedure but required intervention (s)
3
Able to complete procedure without intervention

Case Complexity

1
No difficulty
2
Moderate difficulty (mild inflammation or scarring)
3
Extreme difficulty (severe inflammation, scarring, or abnormal anatomy)